The Benefits Academy
  • Home
  • Products
  • WA State Long Term Care
    • The TBA Alternative
    • More LTC Info
    • LTC Calculator
  • Our Story
    • Fan Page
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Agent Login

Benefits Bites

Whatever Happened to the 3 Rs? The downfall of the ACA.

5/30/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture

​Risk mitigation was built into the ACA but gutted by Congress. Here's our take on the demise of the ACA.

 No, I’m not talking about reading, ‘riting, and ‘rithmatic.  Under the Affordable Care Act (ACA), the 3 Rs are Risk Adjustment, Reinsurance, and Risk Corridors. Initially, as I reviewed the ACA, I was concerned that individual and small group markets would “death spiral” within five years of insurance carriers being required to take all applicants regardless of pre-existing conditions.  Fortunately, the actuaries built in the 3 Rs as risk mitigation; shifting money among insurance companies to help those carriers who ended up with the highest-cost, sickest patients. 

So, buoyed by these fallbacks, the carriers forged ahead:
  • Agreeing to take all enrollees
  • Ignoring health conditions 
  • Charging all members the same rates (by age) regardless of health
  • Covering all pre-existing conditions
  • Basing their rates on “old” pre-ACA claims data 
  • Increasing benefits to the Essential Health Benefit levels
  • Accepting that ACA individual penalties were quite low, and that young healthy individuals might not enroll  
The 3 Rs were important because without them, every year a carrier(s) whose paid claims were much higher than expected would need to increase their rates more substantially than their competitors, causing their members to jump to other carriers’ plans looking for lower rates. As members churn through carriers (who have to accept them), sooner or later, the losing insurance companies exit the market and the whole system starts a death spiral. ☠

But, wait. I just said we have the 3 Rs, right? So, why are we hearing warnings of the death of the small group and individual plan markets?  Well, just because these risk-mitigators were written into the law does not mean Congress can’t change them.

From hopeful beginnings to $14.8B in arrears
Having acted in good faith, today, the majority of insurance carriers have experienced losses.  Some have pulled out of states or counties (or are considering doing so) and some went out of business altogether. All while waiting to be bolstered by the protection of the 3 Rs. Yet, two of the programs are sitting in a deficit position. Here’s how they have fared:
  • Risk Adjustment – Truly net-neutral, funds were transferred among carriers (from those with healthier populations to those with sicker populations).  
  • Reinsurance – This program was estimated to be net-neutral, but it was possible that fees collected might not cover total paid claims for high-cost members.  In 2014, $9.7B in fees were collected and $7.9B were paid to carriers – with the excess rolling to 2015.  Unfortunately, 2015 fees were not adequate; $6.5B in fees were collected and payments owed to carriers were calculated to be $14.3B.  The program is currently in a deficit position, owing carriers $6.5B.  2016 data has yet to be released.
  • Risk Corridor – This program with originally written into the regulations with the assumption that the Federal government would cover deficits. However, Congress removed the federal liability component in the 2015 and 2016 appropriation bills. After 2014 and 2015, this program has a deficit of about $8.3B owed to carriers.  2016 data has not yet been released.
Picture
Why are we only hearing about all of this now?
For a while, rates were stable, primarily because the data just wasn’t there yet.  It takes a while for millions of newly enrolled people to actually go in for care.  Originally for 1/1/2014, carriers based their rates off pre-ACA enrollment data, essentially using insufficient actuarial factors. After all, no one knew how many people would newly enroll on individual and small group plans, how many would move away from these plans due to Medicaid expansion, and how sick the resulting population would end up being.
​
For the 1/1/2015 plans, insurance carriers were required to submit their requested premiums by the end of May, 2014 to State Insurance Commissioners – after only four months of very immature claims data (January 2014 – April 2014).  So again, “guestimate” actuarial factoring had to be incorporated. 
For the 1/1/2016 plans, carriers had more accurate claims data in their actuarial modeling to set rates.  Plus as of May 2015 (the filing deadline), two of the three risk mitigation programs had provided funds to carriers for the 2014 calendar year.  And the third program (the Risk Corridor) was slated to pay out before the end of the year.  Carriers remained optimistic.

Reality bites
In the fall of 2015, just as the new 1/1/2016 plans were about to hit the market for individuals to enroll, the hammer fell on the insurance industry.  Congress put the brakes on funding the Risk Corridor, leaving $2.5B in requested 2014 reimbursements unfunded.  Plus, the carriers could see the writing on the wall that their 2015 losses (totaling another $5.8B) also faced the same fate.  The carriers had three options:
  • Pull all their plan offerings for 2016,
  • Offer only some of the plans they had originally submitted, or
  • Offer them all and hold their breath in the hopes the Federal dollars would eventually materialize. 
In Washington State, Moda pulled out of the market completely, while other carriers culled their plan offerings. 

In early 2016, the insurance carriers were once again calculating rates for the coming year – except now they could factor the loss of Risk Corridor payments from the prior years into their calculations.  But, right before the May 2016 deadline for submitting 1/1/2017 rates, another blow hit the individual market.  News broke that the Reinsurance program, which had a surplus at the end of 2014, ended 2015 with a $6.5B deficit.  The carriers were doing the math and knew that the Risk Corridor was facing over $8B in deficits, with no Congressional appropriations in the wings.  The result: for those carriers still in the individual market, the premium increases were huge. For others, the losses were too great and they either shut down or pulled out of states or counties completely for the 2017 calendar year. 

With the election heating up, the political cry of “Obamacare is failing” was a key factor contributing to a Republican majority sweep.  Too bad most Americans did not understand that the ACA was cut off at the knees before being given a chance to run the race.
Picture
The perfect storm
This was the perfect storm, and it was set in motion because the ACA promised one thing and Congress changed the rules of the game midstream.  Some say it was an orchestrated bid to make Obamacare look as bad as possible for the 2016 election cycle. Maybe. But, the carriers aren’t going to play this game while their losses continue to mount.  There are a number of lawsuits by carriers against the Federal government.  And now it seems that every week another insurance company is announcing their exit from offering coverage in states or counties.  With the losses throughout the industry, it is easy to see why entire insurance markets are on the brink of collapse.  Here are the Pacific Northwest statistics.
​
Where do we go from here?
I fail to see how any of the new-fangled versions of the ACA – be it the AHCA or whatever the Senate is working on – can create an effective, stable system without providing a safety net for the insurance carriers. When we end up with single payor government coverage because all the private carriers bugged out, you’ll know that Congress’ failure to understand the value of the 3 Rs is what collapsed the individual market.  The insurance carriers erred in trusting the feds.  They won’t make that mistake again.  Once bitten, twice shy…it’s an actuarially proven fact.

Stay up on the latest and greatest.

We're closely monitoring the events in the other Washington and bringing you the current non-alternative facts and commentary.  Make sure you are in-the-know by subscribing to our Benefits Bites newsletter and/or for all the industry news, please follow us on LinkedIn or like us on Facebook.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    This section will not be visible in live published website. Below are your current settings:


    Current Number Of Columns are = 1

    Expand Posts Area =

    Gap/Space Between Posts = 10px

    Blog Post Style = card

    Use of custom card colors instead of default colors =

    Blog Post Card Background Color = current color

    Blog Post Card Shadow Color = current color

    Blog Post Card Border Color = current color

    Publish the website and visit your blog page to see the results

    About Sandy

    I love numbers.  I'm a math geek. I read benefits industry articles and periodicals for relaxation (but, honestly, I'm still a fun gal).  I also like to share what I've learned and you'll find it all here.

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    September 2022
    July 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016

    Categories

    All
    2017
    2018
    2019
    2020
    2021
    2022
    2023
    ACA
    ACA Lawsuits
    ACA Reporting
    ADA
    Aetna
    Age-banded Rates
    AHP
    Ambetter
    Association Health Plans
    Associations
    Asuris
    Balanced Billing
    Benefit Bites
    Benefits Coordination
    Biden Administration
    Bridgespan
    Bridge Span
    Busy Season
    Carrier Corner
    Carrier Exit
    Cascade Care
    CMS
    COBRA
    Community Health Plan
    Community Rated Plans
    Compliance Notices
    Continuation
    Conversion
    Coordinated Care
    Coronavirus
    Cost Sharing Programs
    Cost Sharing Reduction
    Data Match
    Dependents
    Direct Primary Care Programs
    Disability Insurance
    Domestic Partners
    EIDL
    Executive Order
    Facility Fees
    Facility Scope Creep
    FAIR Health
    FFCRA
    FSA
    Group Health
    Group Life
    HDHP
    Health Alliance NW
    Healthnet
    Health Savings Account
    Heart Health
    HRA
    HSA
    ICHRA
    Individual
    Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement
    Individualized Medicine
    Individual Mandate
    Individual Penalty
    IRS
    Kaiser
    Kaiser NW
    Kaiser WA
    Life Insurance
    Lifewise
    Long Term Care
    Long Term Care Services And Support Trust Act
    Mandate
    Medicaid
    Medicare
    Medicare For All
    Micro Group
    Moda
    Molina
    Monthly Freebies
    Networks
    Nondiscrimination Testing
    Notice Requirements
    Paid Family & Medical Leave
    Pandemic
    Part D
    Partnership
    PCT Updates
    Penalties
    PFML
    Pharmacogenomics
    Plan Comparison Tool
    Portability
    PPO Networks
    PPP
    Premera
    Prescription Assistance Programs
    Pre-Tax Premiums
    Providence
    PTO
    Public Option
    QSEHRA
    Rates
    Referenced Based Pricing
    Regence
    Regence OR
    Reinsurance
    Renewals
    Repeal
    Risk Adjustment
    Risk Corridor
    Rx Copay Accumulator Programs
    S-Corp
    Section 105(h)
    Section 125
    Section 79
    Self Funded
    Self-funded
    Short Term Medical Plans
    Single Payer
    Small Employer Health Credit
    Small Group
    Social Distancing
    Stimulus
    Subsidies
    Tax Credits
    Trump
    Trust Plans
    Uninsured
    United Hea
    United Healthcare
    Vetted Vendor
    WA Cares
    WA LTC
    WA OIC
    Washington State
    Wellness Program

    RSS Feed

Services

Products
Resources

Company

Our Story
Blog
​Fans

Support

Contact
​Agent Login
© COPYRIGHT 2020. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • Home
  • Products
  • WA State Long Term Care
    • The TBA Alternative
    • More LTC Info
    • LTC Calculator
  • Our Story
    • Fan Page
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Agent Login